An Expensive Experiment

Image source:

What's going on?

A two-year experiment by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to get banks and investors to care more about smaller companies has cost said investors $300 million. Oops.

What does this mean?

The “Tick Size Pilot Program” changed how stocks of smaller companies traded. Under the test (which included 1,400 stocks), when stocks moved up or down, they moved by bigger increments. So if a share price was $5.00, instead of moving to $5.01, it would be $5.05. This way, banks get more money from trading (bigger stock moves means more money from fees). The hope was that banks would then write more research – helping investors to understand these stocks and invest. A win for everyone, right?


Not quite. According to BlackRock, the cost to buy and sell stocks of smaller companies has risen by 35-45% (tweet this). However, banks haven’t seemed willing to hire people to do more research on the back of an experiment.

Why should I care?

The bigger picture: Markets are stuck in a halfway house.


The SEC’s currently in a chicken and egg situation. Because the program’s a test, banks won’t commit big money to beef up their research teams in case the regulation doesn’t stick. Even if it does, they may want to stay lean and make more profit. In the UK, tighter regulations from MiFID II (which makes it easier for investors to see what prices they’re paying for trading services) has reduced trading revenue for lots of banks (as they aren’t able to charge as high fees) and caused many to cut jobs (Japanese investment bank Nomura cut a chunk of its European business).



For you, personally: Look forward to higher costs to trade.


Huge global asset managers like BlackRock and Fidelity have billions locked up for investment, which most likely includes some of your pension – if you have one. So the higher costs they’re facing will likely fall at your feet in the form of higher fees. If they’re growing your money, it won’t be for free.

Originally posted as part of the Finimize daily email.

The top 2 financial news stories in 3 minutes. Join over one million Finimizers

Read next

Keep Calm And Carry On

Sign up to Finimize

Get the two most important global financial news stories each day. Sent at midnight UK time.

Get started with one email a day

The top financial news stories in 3 minutes.